7even.Independent market research · India
Menu

7even / The ledger

The ledger.

Our investigations, and short pieces that make a testable call, each state one claim about what the data shows and name what would prove it wrong. This page tracks each claim after it goes out. When the evidence moves, the row is updated in public, with the date, and the old entry stays. A claim here is a reading of the evidence, not a view on where a price is heading. Nothing on this page is a recommendation to buy or sell.

On the record9 claims on record4 holding1 updated4 watching

What each status means

Holds

The evidence since publishing still supports the claim.

Watching

The test hasn't arrived yet (a result, a filing, an index review).

Updated

New evidence refined the claim; the note explains how.

Broken

The evidence went against the claim. It stays here, with the date and what changed.

Claims on record

Showing 9 claims.

If MSCI moves Indonesia out of its Emerging Markets index, the removal itself lifts India's share of that index by less than 0.1 of a percentage point.Investigation · Indonesia may leave MSCI's emerging markets index. India's share would rise by about 0.05 points.WatchingNext check by 30 Jun 2027MSCI's own figures when it announces or carries out the change show India's share rising by 0.1 of a percentage point or more because of Indonesia's removal, which needs Indonesia to be about 0.93% of the index, more than double its 0.43% on 30 Sep 2026. Read at the decision and again at implementation, if later.
Jio and Airtel lost the argument for a satellite spectrum auction, but through their Starlink distribution deals and satellite stakes both already sit on the satellite side, whichever way the fee lands.Investigation · Jio asked for an auction. Then it signed up to sell Starlink.WatchingNext check by 30 Nov 2026The Cabinet moves satcom spectrum to auction or restores an urban per-subscriber charge.

Dated history

  1. Watching

    Published.

  2. Watching

    The 5% of AGR rate cleared by the Digital Communications Commission in early September was still awaiting Cabinet approval on 1 Oct 2026.

  3. Watching

    No Cabinet decision on satcom spectrum pricing had been reported by 9 Nov 2026. The proposal before the Cabinet is administrative allocation at 5% of adjusted gross revenue with a lower rate for remote areas and no urban per-subscriber charge. Neither an auction nor an urban per-subscriber charge has been adopted, so the test has not arrived.

EvidencePress Information Bureau, Cabinet releases Communications Today, 12 Oct 2026 IANS, 26 Oct 2026 Light Reading, 11 Sep 2026

India's fall in MSCI EM weight, from nearly 21% in Sep 2024 to 10.87% in May 2026, came mainly from the AI-chip rally in Taiwan and Korea lifting the rest of the index, not from a collapse in India.Investigation · India Has No Seat at the AI Table. Its Index Weight Is Paying for It.HoldsNext check by 1 Dec 2026India's weight rises while the chip makers' combined weight also rises, or India gains meaningful AI-hardware weight.

Dated history

  1. Watching

    Published.

  2. Holds

    After MSCI's August 2026 review, TSMC's weight rose to 15.14% while India's edged up to 11.25%, and the new Indian additions were pharma, eyewear, power transmission and fintech, not chip makers.

EvidenceMSCI Emerging Markets factsheet, 31 Aug 2026

Jio and retail together already earn about half of Reliance's EBITDA, ahead of oil-to-chemicals, so the Jio IPO reveals value already earned rather than creating it.Quick Take · Reliance’s largest profit engine is no longer oil.HoldsNext check by 31 Jan 2027Q2 FY27 segment results show Jio and retail below oil-to-chemicals.

Dated history

  1. Watching

    Published.

  2. Holds

    Q1 FY27 segment results again showed Jio and retail at about half of group EBITDA, ahead of oil-to-chemicals, and Jio's IPO filing shows FY26 EBITDA of ₹76,255 crore.

  3. Holds

    Reliance reported Q2 FY27 on 30 Oct 2026. Digital Services EBITDA was ₹22,223 crore and Retail ₹6,120 crore, together ₹28,343 crore, ahead of oil-to-chemicals at ₹25,203 crore, so the test in the claim was not met. The gap narrowed: oil-to-chemicals EBITDA rose 67.9% on the year with a steep rise in fuel cracks and petrochemical margins, and Digital Services and Retail together fell to about 45% of group EBITDA of ₹62,409 crore, from about 51% a year earlier. Jio Platforms listed on 28 Oct 2026 after a ₹30,188 crore IPO.

EvidenceReliance Q2 FY27 investor presentation, slide 9 (NSE filing, 30 Oct 2026) Reliance Q2 FY27 media release (NSE filing, 30 Oct 2026) Reliance, listing of Jio Platforms shares (NSE filing, 27 Oct 2026) Tribune, Reliance Q1 FY27 results, 17 Jul 2026

The ₹1.75 lakh crore of approved but unlaunched IPOs is deferred supply competing for the same domestic money; with foreign investors selling, absorbing it becomes the constraint.Investigation · A Delayed IPO Doesn't Disappear. It Joins a ₹1.75 Lakh Crore Wall.WatchingNext check by 30 Nov 2026Jio and NSE list with strong demand and no visible drain on secondary-market flows.

Dated history

  1. Watching

    Published.

  2. Watching

    The September deadline rush brought smaller issues, but the largest (Jio, NSE) are still to price; foreign investors sold again in September after buying in July and August.

  3. Watching

    Correction to the 1 Oct 2026 line: NSE had already priced and listed by then, on 24 Sep 2026; only Jio was still to price.

  4. Watching

    Both large issues have now listed. NSE listed on BSE on 24 Sep 2026 after an offer for sale of ₹22,562 crore; Jio Platforms listed on 28 Oct 2026 after a ₹30,188 crore fresh issue. Foreign investors were net sellers of Indian equities in October. The second half of the test, whether the listings drew money away from the secondary market, has not yet been read against exchange and depository flow data.

EvidenceAngel One, FPI flows, Sep 2026 BSE notice 20260923-1, listing of equity shares of National Stock Exchange of India Limited, 23 Sep 2026 Reliance Industries, listing of Jio Platforms shares from 28 Oct 2026 (NSE filing, 27 Oct 2026) Reliance Industries, Q2 FY27 media release (NSE filing, 30 Oct 2026)

Indian IT was marked down on Accenture's guidance cut before any Indian firm reported; if TCS and Infosys echoed the caution in July, the read-through was right, not an overreaction.Quick Take · Indian IT repriced on a number that wasn’t theirs.HoldsNext check by 31 Jan 2027TCS and Infosys report recovering North American demand in Q2 FY27 and Infosys raises its guidance.

Dated history

  1. Watching

    Published.

  2. Updated

    Infosys cut its FY27 growth guidance on 23 Jul 2026, citing North American caution; TCS was softer but more hopeful about Q2, so the read-through held for Infosys and only partly for TCS.

  3. Holds

    Both test results are in, and neither showed the recovery that would have proved the read-through wrong. Infosys reported Q2 FY27 on 23 Oct 2026 and cut its FY27 revenue growth guidance again, to 1% to 2% in constant currency from the 1.5% to 3.0% it gave in July; its North America revenue fell 1.5% on the year in constant currency while the whole company grew 1.5%, and North America's share of revenue fell to 54.6% from 56.4% in the June quarter. TCS, on 8 Oct 2026, reported North America growth of 1.5% on the year in constant currency against 2.8% for the whole company.

EvidenceInfosys Q2 FY27 results (NSE filing, 23 Oct 2026) Infosys Q1 FY27 results (NSE filing, 23 Jul 2026) TCS Q2 FY27 press release (NSE filing, 8 Oct 2026) Upstox, Infosys Q1 FY27 results

Aegis is an oil-import infrastructure business (a toll booth on India's energy imports), and its valuation already prices in the terminal growth story.Investigation · Whoever Sells India Its Energy, It Still Lands Through the Same TerminalsUpdatedNext check by 30 Nov 2026Terminal throughput grows fast enough that terminal earnings alone support the valuation.

Dated history

  1. Watching

    Published.

  2. Updated

    Q1 FY27 profit rose 211%, but the gas distribution business drove it (LPG volumes up 91%) while terminal throughput fell 3%; the earnings came from trading, not the toll booth, and the multiple rose further.

  3. Updated

    Aegis reported Q2 FY27 results on 26 Oct 2026. In its consolidated segment table (segment results are before finance costs, unallocated items and tax), the liquid terminal division's result rose to ₹120.47 crore from ₹91.68 crore a year earlier and ₹109.70 crore in the June quarter. The gas terminal division's result fell to ₹277.70 crore from ₹575.13 crore in the June quarter, though it was above the ₹196.15 crore of a year earlier. Liquids made up about 30% of segment results in the quarter, against about 16% in the June quarter, mainly because the gas result fell. The results filing does not give terminal throughput, and the company's Q2 earnings call was on 3 Nov 2026, so the trigger has not yet been tested.

EvidenceAegis Q1 FY27 investor presentation (NSE filing, 6 Aug 2026) Aegis Logistics, Q2 FY27 results, consolidated segment information, page 13 (NSE filing, 26 Oct 2026)

The RBI's switch to expected-credit-loss provisioning from 1 Apr 2027 is a material change to bank earnings and capital that the market has not priced.Investigation · On 1 April 2027, Banks Start Reserving for Losses Before They HappenWatchingNext check by 31 Jan 2027Large banks disclose an ECL hit well below agency estimates, or say existing buffers absorb it fully.

Dated history

  1. Watching

    Published.

  2. Watching

    As of 1 Oct 2026 no bank has quantified its own ECL impact; the only sizing remains agency estimates (CRISIL: up to 120 bps of net CET1 over the transition).

  3. Watching

    SBI, the largest bank, is the first to give a net figure for its own loan book. Its chairman said at the 3 Nov 2026 analyst meet that the transition impact on loans is ₹19,500 crore net of tax, after adjusting all existing provisions, and that SBI will spread it over the four-year transition; it excludes fair valuation of the held-to-maturity bond book and crop loans, which are not yet final and could raise it. He was reported the same day as putting the hit to CET1 capital at 40 to 50 basis points. CRISIL Ratings' estimate for most banks is a net hit of up to 120 basis points of CET1. Earlier, Punjab National Bank, Canara Bank and Indian Bank gave rupee estimates on their calls, and other large banks filed Q2 FY27 results with no ECL figure. No large bank has said its existing buffers absorb the change in full. The test has not arrived.

EvidenceCRISIL Ratings press release, Apr 2026 State Bank of India, Q2 FY27 analyst meet transcript, 3 Nov 2026 (BSE filing, 7 Nov 2026) Business Standard, 3 Nov 2026 (news, supporting)

RVNL's drawdown was the price correcting, not a valuation re-rating: its earnings multiple stayed well above its peers'.Investigation · RVNL Crashed 64%. It Still Trades at 56 Times Earnings.HoldsNext check by 23 Nov 2026RVNL's multiple falls to within the peer range while peers hold their June levels.

Dated history

  1. Watching

    Published.

  2. Holds

    On 30 Sep 2026 RVNL traded at about 50 to 53 times trailing earnings, against 56 times when we wrote, still well above listed infrastructure peers; the price fell more than the multiple.

  3. Holds

    RVNL's board meets on 13 Nov 2026 to approve Q2 FY27 results, so the test, which compares RVNL's multiple with its peers', waits for those results. On 8 Nov 2026 Screener.in showed RVNL at 45.1 times trailing earnings, against about 50 to 53 times on 30 Sep 2026 and 56 times when we wrote.

EvidenceScreener.in, RVNL consolidated financials and P/E

Open a row to see its dated history and evidence. Archive-only pieces, which make no testable call, stay in the Reading Room.