23 Oct 2026 · Everyday · Money in Motion
A monthly SIP in a fund that tracks 50 large companies (the NIFTY 50), started in any month from July 2023 to September 2026, was worth less on 22 Oct than the money put in. An SIP puts a fixed amount into a fund every month.
We ran that SIP from every start month from February 2022, on AMFI's daily NAVs (the value of one unit) for three NIFTY 50 index funds and two that track 250 smaller companies (the NIFTY Smallcap 250). Started in October 2023: about 2% behind in the big-company funds, about 5% ahead in the small-company ones. The small-company SIPs were ahead for 49 of the 57 start months.
The catch: small companies swing harder. On 23 Mar 2026, small-company SIPs from 37 of 50 start months were behind.
On 22 Oct, the big-company SIPs were the ones in the red, and the small-company ones mostly were not. What held the big companies back?
Research, not advice. Do your own work.
