Four state-owned (public sector) banks have put a rupee figure on the RBI's new loan-loss rule. On their July to September calls, the four private banks we read did not: one gave a share of its net worth, one gave a verdict, and two did not mention the rule.

From 1 Apr 2027, banks move to expected-credit-loss provisioning (ECL): money set aside for loans that may go bad in future, not only for loans that already have. The RBI's directions of 27 Apr 2026 treat the one-time cost of the switch as a gap that is taken straight against the bank's reserves on 1 Apr 2027 (its accumulated past profits), not charged to that year's profit and loss account.

We have already read what four state-owned banks said on their calls: SBI ₹19,500 crore, Bank of Baroda about ₹12,500 crore, Canara Bank ₹12,000 to ₹15,000 crore and PNB about ₹8,000 crore. Their bases differ, so the four do not add up to one total.

The private banks describe the same rule in other ways:

  • Kotak Mahindra Bank (call on 24 Oct): the one-time effect "will be less than 2% of the net worth", net worth being the shareholders' money in the bank, ₹1,45,984 crore at 30 Sep. On that base, taking the bank's own net worth rather than the group's, 2% is about ₹2,920 crore. That figure is our arithmetic, a ceiling Kotak did not state in rupees. On the yearly running cost, Kotak said it would wait for "further clarity".
  • Axis Bank (call on 17 Oct): its CFO said "we don't expect any material impact to come through on the transition itself", helped by existing contingent provisions (provisions Axis already holds) of "almost close to 8,000 crores". He did not put a number on the yearly cost.
  • HDFC Bank and ICICI Bank (calls on 17 Oct): the rule does not come up in either bank's call transcript.

So the same rule is being described in four ways: rupees, a share of net worth, a verdict and silence. A rupee figure and a share of net worth cannot be set side by side without each bank's net worth, and a verdict cannot be set beside anything.

Here's the catch. We read call transcripts only, not annual reports or investor decks, so silence on a call is not proof that a bank has no estimate. Axis's verdict is a judgement, not a number, and all of it was said aloud on a call, not audited.

Without a common unit, how should anyone compare what the banks have said so far?

Research, not advice. Do your own work.

Ecl how banks describe · Four state-owned (public sector) banks have put a rupee figure on the RBI's new loan-loss rule.
Figure · Open at full size